Restaurant HR support, a PEO, or payroll software: what actually changes
By Dan MurphyUpdated 8 min read
What is the difference between restaurant HR support, a PEO, and payroll software?
Payroll software gives you a system to run payroll in but no one to prepare it. A PEO becomes a co-employer, taking on employment liability and typically charging per employee per month. An HR-administration service like BOHO does the recurring preparation and record-keeping while your restaurant stays the sole employer and keeps every approval.
These three things get compared as if they were competing products. They are not. They are three different answers to the question who does this work and who carries the risk, and choosing well means being honest about which of those two problems you actually have.
Written by a service that is one of the three. Where that shapes the framing, it is flagged.
Payroll software
What it is. A system you run payroll in. It calculates, files, and pays, and it does those things well.
What it does not do. It does not assemble your inputs. Software does not chase a manager for a missing timecard, notice that a new hire was never reported to the state, ask why a deduction has no signed authorization, or maintain the personnel file behind a termination. It processes what you give it, accurately, including the parts that are wrong.
Who it suits. A restaurant where someone competent has the time to do payroll preparation properly and reliably every cycle. If that person exists, software is the cheapest correct answer and you should stop reading here.
The failure mode. The person who was doing it well gets busy, or leaves. Preparation quality degrades gradually and the problems surface a quarter or two later.
A PEO
What it is. A professional employer organization enters a co-employment relationship with your business. It becomes an employer of record for certain purposes, and takes on defined employment obligations alongside you.
What you get. Genuine transfer of some employment risk, access to benefits programs a small restaurant would struggle to obtain alone, and a broad HR infrastructure.
What you give up. Some control over employment processes, and typically a per-employee cost structure. For a restaurant whose headcount swings seasonally, a per-employee model means your admin cost rises in exactly the months you are busiest.
Who it suits. An operator whose actual problem is risk and benefits rather than paperwork throughput — or one who genuinely wants the employment relationship handled by someone else.
The failure mode. Buying a PEO to solve a paperwork problem. You pay for risk transfer you did not need, and the restaurant still has to feed the process.
Note on fairness: PEO pricing and terms vary widely between providers and over time. This page does not quote competitor pricing, because a stated figure would be out of date almost immediately. Get current quotes.
An HR administration service
What it is. A service that does the recurring preparation and record-keeping while your restaurant remains the sole employer. This is what BOHO is.
What you get. The inputs assembled, exceptions surfaced, files maintained, onboarding sequenced, and the payroll run prepared — with a client approval gate before anything is submitted.
What you do not get. No risk transfer. You remain the employer of record, you make every employment decision, you fund payroll, and you carry the employment relationship. If what you wanted was for someone else to be the employer, this is the wrong product and a PEO is the right one.
Who it suits. An operator whose problem is that the work has no home — and who wants to keep control of employment decisions rather than share it.
The failure mode. Expecting it to absorb liability it explicitly does not absorb. This is why BOHO publishes a line-by-line scope page before anyone becomes a client.
The comparison in one table
| Feature | Payroll software | PEO | BOHOHR admin service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who is the employer of record | You | Shared (co-employment) | You |
| Who prepares the payroll | You | Provider | Provider, you approve |
| Who approves before submission | You | Varies | You, always |
| Employment risk transfer | None | Defined transfer | None |
| Benefits access | No | Often a core reason to buy | No |
| Typical cost basis | Per run or per employee | Typically per employee | Flat retainer (BOHO) |
| Maintains your personnel files | No | Usually | Yes |
| Makes employment decisions | No | Shared in part | No — never |
How to actually decide
Two questions settle it faster than a feature comparison.
- Do you want to stop being the employer? If yes, you want a PEO. Nothing else on this page does that, and no amount of administrative help substitutes for it.
- Is there someone who reliably prepares payroll properly every cycle? If yes, buy software. If that person is you and you are doing it at 11pm on a Sunday, that is not a yes.
If you want to remain the employer and there is nobody with the time to prepare the work properly, that is the gap an administration service fills. If you are switching from an existing provider, the payroll transition checklist covers what to gather first.
Questions to ask any of the three
- Who is the employer of record after we sign?
- Who prepares the payroll run, and who approves it before submission?
- Name every cost that is not in the recurring fee.
- What happens when we are wrong — and what happens when you are?
- What is explicitly outside the scope? Ask for it in writing.
- What is the exit process, and who holds our records afterwards?
A provider that answers the fifth question quickly and in writing is telling you something useful about all the others.
FAQ
Questions restaurant owners ask
How is this different from just buying payroll software?
Payroll software gives you a system to run payroll in. It does not assemble your inputs, chase a manager for a missing timecard, notice that a new hire was never reported, or maintain the personnel file behind a termination. BOHO is the person doing that work; the software is where the run happens.
Keep reading
Related resources
Restaurant HR administration
The people-operations checklist a restaurant owner can review each month
What HR items should a restaurant owner review each month?
6 min read · Updated
Restaurant payroll coordination
What to organize before moving a restaurant payroll workflow
What do you need before switching restaurant payroll providers?
7 min read · Updated
Want this running without you chasing it?
Your restaurant remains the employer of record and approves payroll and employment decisions. BOHO is not a PEO, a staffing agency, or legal counsel.